Syllogism: Possibility Cases

A regular Syllogism conclusion has to hold in EVERY valid diagram to follow. A possibility conclusion only needs to hold in AT LEAST ONE valid diagram consistent with the statements — a much lower bar, and a different question entirely. Here’s the approach, six fully worked examples covering each pattern, and a few to try yourself.

Written by Mahesh Srivastava, Founder of Pariksha Saathi. Published: 2026-10-03. Editorial standards & corrections

Jump to practice questions ↓

The approach, quickly

  • A possibility conclusion ("it is possible that...") is valid if you can draw even ONE diagram consistent with the statements where it holds — it does not need to hold in every diagram, unlike a regular "definitely follows" conclusion.
  • A possibility conclusion is NOT valid only when it’s impossible in every single diagram consistent with the statements — meaning the statements actively rule it out, not just fail to guarantee it.
  • Two "Some" statements, or a "Some" combined with another statement, usually leave real freedom in how the circles overlap — this is where both a positive and a negative possibility often turn out valid at once.
  • When one category is fully nested inside another that’s fully separate from a third (an "All" chained into a "No"), the nested category and the separate one can never overlap in any diagram — ruling out any possibility conclusion that requires them to.
  • When two categories have NO statement linking them directly or transitively, their relationship is completely unconstrained — in that case, both "some X are Y" and "no X are Y" are typically valid possibilities at once, since nothing in the statements rules either one out.

Worked examples

1. Statements: Some pens are books. Some books are tables. Possibilities: I. It is possible that some pens are tables. II. It is possible that no pens are tables.

Solution

  1. The "books that are pens" and the "books that are tables" could be the same books (making some pens tables) or entirely different books (making no pens tables) — both are consistent with the statements.

Answer: Both possibilities are valid

2. Statements: No pen is a book. All books are tables. Possibilities: I. It is possible that some tables are pens. II. It is possible that all tables are pens.

Solution

  1. Tables include all the books, but could also include other members beyond just books — those other members could be pens, so "some tables are pens" is possible.
  2. But the book-tables can never be pens (since no pen is a book), so not every table can possibly be a pen — "all tables are pens" is ruled out.

Answer: Only possibility I is valid

3. Statements: All pens are books. No book is a table. Possibilities: I. It is possible that some pens are tables. II. It is possible that all tables are pens.

Solution

  1. Since every pen is a book, and no book is a table, pens and tables can never overlap in any valid diagram — ruling out both "some pens are tables" and the stronger "all tables are pens."

Answer: Neither possibility is valid

4. Statements: Some pens are books. No book is a table. Possibilities: I. It is possible that all pens are tables. II. It is possible that some pens are tables.

Solution

  1. Since books are never tables, any pen that is also a book cannot be a table — and "some pens are books" guarantees at least one such pen, so not every pen can possibly be a table, ruling out "all pens are tables."
  2. But pens outside that book-overlap aren’t constrained at all — some of them could be tables, making "some pens are tables" possible.

Answer: Only possibility II is valid

5. Statements: All pens are books. Some books are tables. Possibilities: I. It is possible that all pens are tables. II. It is possible that no pens are tables.

Solution

  1. Since pens are a subset of books, and "Some books are tables" fixes only that at least one book is a table (not which ones, or how many), nothing forces any particular pen to be (or not be) among the table-books.
  2. If the pen-books happen to be exactly the table-books, all pens could be tables — possible. If the pen-books fall entirely outside the table-books, no pens are tables — also possible.

Answer: Both possibilities are valid

6. Statements: No pen is a book. No book is a table. Possibilities: I. It is possible that some pens are tables. II. It is possible that no pens are tables.

Solution

  1. Both statements only constrain pens and tables relative to books — neither statement says anything about pens and tables directly.
  2. With no direct or transitive link between pens and tables, their circles are free to overlap partially, fully, or not at all — both "some pens are tables" and "no pens are tables" are consistent with the given statements.

Answer: Both possibilities are valid

Common mistakes and more worked examples

This section was added on 10 November 2026. It was drafted with AI assistance and checked by a second, independent pass, with every number recomputed. Published by Mahesh Srivastava, who corrects any error you report.

Common mistakes

  • Marking a conclusion that definitely follows as "not a possibility". If it holds in every valid diagram, it holds in at least one, so its possibility is valid too (for example, "some pens are tables" when some pens are books and all books are tables).
  • Forgetting that every category in the statements exists. When no pen is a book and all books are tables, "all tables are pens" is impossible, because the books are tables that can never be pens.
  • Reading "Some" as "only some". "Some pens are books" still allows every pen to be a book, so "it is possible that all pens are books" is valid; only a statement such as "Only a few pens are books" rules that out.
  • Rejecting a possibility because it fails in the first diagram you drew. A possibility is invalid only when no valid diagram allows it, so try redrawing the circles to make it true before rejecting it.
  • Treating "All pens are books" as ruling out the reverse. It does not stop the two groups from being exactly the same, so "it is possible that all books are pens" is valid.
  • Accepting a possibility that goes against what the statements force. When all pens are books and all books are tables, every pen is a table, so "it is possible that some pens are not tables" is invalid.

More worked examples

7. Statements: All flowers are fruits. Some fruits are trees. No tree is a stone. Possibilities: I. It is possible that some flowers are stones. II. It is possible that all fruits are stones.

Solution

  1. Flowers lie inside fruits. "Some fruits are trees" does not make every fruit a tree, so there can be fruits that are not trees, and the flowers can sit in that part. Stones are kept away only from trees, so those flowers can overlap stones — I is possible.
  2. "Some fruits are trees" guarantees fruits that are trees, and those can never be stones (no tree is a stone). So not every fruit can be a stone — II is ruled out.

Answer: Only possibility I is valid

8. Statements: Only a few flowers are fruits. All fruits are trees. Possibilities: I. It is possible that all flowers are fruits. II. It is possible that all flowers are trees.

Solution

  1. "Only a few flowers are fruits" means some flowers are fruits AND some flowers are not fruits. "All flowers are fruits" goes against this — I is ruled out. (With a plain "Some flowers are fruits", I would have been possible.)
  2. The flowers that are fruits are trees, since all fruits are trees. The flowers that are not fruits are not limited by any statement, so they can be trees too — then every flower is a tree. II is possible.

Answer: Only possibility II is valid

9. Statements: Some fruits are not trees. All stones are trees. Possibilities: I. It is possible that all fruits are stones. II. It is possible that some fruits are stones.

Solution

  1. If all fruits were stones, then, since all stones are trees, all fruits would be trees. That goes against "some fruits are not trees" — I is ruled out.
  2. "Some fruits are not trees" says nothing about the other fruits: some fruits can still be trees, and those can be stones. So "some fruits are stones" fits both statements — II is possible.

Answer: Only possibility II is valid

Try these yourself

Check whether each possibility can be drawn in at least one valid diagram, then check against the answer.

1. Statements: Some pens are books. All books are tables. Possibilities: I. It is possible that some pens are tables. II. It is possible that no pens are tables.

Answer: Only possibility I is valid

2. Statements: No pen is a book. Some books are tables. Possibilities: I. It is possible that some pens are tables. II. It is possible that no pens are tables.

Answer: Both possibilities are valid

3. Statements: All pens are books. All books are tables. Possibilities: I. It is possible that all pens are tables. II. It is possible that no pens are tables.

Answer: Only possibility I is valid

4. Statements: All pens are books. All books are tables. Possibilities: I. It is possible that some tables are not pens. II. It is possible that no pens are tables.

Answer: Only possibility I is valid (every pen is forced to be a table by the chain, so II is impossible)

5. Statements: Some pens are books. All books are tables. Possibilities: I. It is possible that some pens are not tables. II. It is possible that all pens are tables.

Answer: Both possibilities are valid

All 11 practice questions on Syllogism: Possibility Cases, with answers →

Where this comes up

Among the exams Pariksha Saathi covers, Syllogism is named in the Reasoning/General Intelligence syllabus of SSC CGL, RRB NTPC, RRB Group D, RRB ALP, IBPS PO, IBPS Clerk, SBI PO and SBI Clerk (for any other exam, check your own exam’s official notification); Possibility Cases are a form of Syllogism question and build on the standard Syllogism lesson.

Keep practising

Solve the questions above before opening the answers. Explain each step in your own words, then revisit any mistakes.

Go to practice questions →

Explore the lesson library