Statement and Argument Solved Questions

A strong argument gives a specific, weighty reason that directly addresses the question — a weak argument is vague, trivial, or beside the point, even if it sounds reasonable on first read. Here’s the approach, six fully worked examples covering each possible pattern, and a few to try yourself.

Written by Mahesh Srivastava, Founder of Pariksha Saathi. Published: 2026-10-03. Editorial standards & corrections

Jump to practice questions ↓

The approach, quickly

  • A strong argument must be both relevant to the question and important/weighty — a real, practical consequence or reason, not a passing preference or a superficial point.
  • An argument that states a general truism, a vague preference ("people like X"), or a throwaway comparison to something unrelated is weak, even if it isn’t factually wrong.
  • An argument that doesn’t actually address the specific question asked — or answers a different, broader question — is weak, however reasonable it sounds standing alone.
  • Judge "yes" and "no" arguments independently of each other — a question can have a strong case on both sides, on neither side, or on only one.
  • An argument built on a vague, unspecified fear ("it could be misused," "something might go wrong") is weak unless it explains specifically how or why that risk is likely — a specific, named consequence is strong; a generic worry is not.

Worked examples

1. Statement: Should voting be made mandatory for all eligible citizens? Arguments: I. Yes, mandatory voting would increase voter turnout and ensure governments better reflect the will of the majority. II. No, people should be free to do whatever they want.

Solution

  1. I: Gives a specific, weighty reason — better representation through higher turnout. Strong.
  2. II: A vague generalization about freedom that doesn’t engage with the specific tradeoffs of mandatory voting. Weak.

Answer: Only argument I is strong

2. Statement: Should smoking be banned in all public places? Arguments: I. No, people have been smoking for centuries, so it should continue. II. Yes, passive smoking harms the health of non-smokers who have no choice in the matter.

Solution

  1. I: Tradition alone isn’t a reason to continue something with proven harms — this doesn’t engage with the actual issue. Weak.
  2. II: A specific, weighty harm to non-consenting third parties — directly relevant to why a ban might be justified. Strong.

Answer: Only argument II is strong

3. Statement: Should schools introduce compulsory computer education from an early age? Arguments: I. Yes, early exposure to technology will better prepare students for a digital economy. II. No, it would require significant investment in infrastructure and teacher training that many schools cannot currently afford.

Solution

  1. I: A specific, weighty future benefit directly tied to the proposal. Strong.
  2. II: A specific, weighty practical constraint directly tied to the proposal. Strong.

Answer: Both arguments are strong

4. Statement: Should the government increase funding for space research? Arguments: I. Yes, because space is vast and interesting. II. No, because other countries also fund space research.

Solution

  1. I: "Interesting" isn’t a weighty justification for a funding priority — too vague. Weak.
  2. II: Other countries’ funding choices don’t address whether this government should increase its own funding. Weak.

Answer: Neither argument is strong

5. Statement: Should the use of private vehicles be restricted in city centres? Arguments: I. Yes, it would reduce traffic congestion and air pollution in densely populated areas. II. No, because some people might not like the restriction.

Solution

  1. I: Names specific, weighty, measurable consequences (congestion, pollution) directly tied to the proposal. Strong.
  2. II: "Might not like it" is a vague personal reaction, not a weighty practical consequence. Weak.

Answer: Only argument I is strong

6. Statement: Should higher education be made completely free for all students? Arguments: I. Yes, it would make education accessible to economically weaker sections who currently cannot afford it. II. No, it would require the government to allocate significantly more funds, which could affect other essential public services.

Solution

  1. I: A specific, weighty benefit (access for those currently priced out) directly tied to the proposal. Strong.
  2. II: A specific, weighty cost (funding tradeoffs against other services) directly tied to the proposal. Strong.

Answer: Both arguments are strong

Try these yourself

Judge each argument on relevance and weight, then check against the answer.

1. Statement: Should plastic bags be banned in retail stores? Arguments: I. Yes, plastic bags take hundreds of years to decompose and cause significant environmental harm. II. No, people like using plastic bags.

Answer: Only argument I is strong

2. Statement: Should employees be allowed to work from home permanently? Arguments: I. Yes, it reduces commuting time and increases work-life balance for employees. II. No, it can reduce spontaneous collaboration and weaken team cohesion over time.

Answer: Both arguments are strong

3. Statement: Should the city build a new stadium? Arguments: I. Yes, because sports are fun. II. No, because the old stadium has a long history.

Answer: Neither argument is strong

4. Statement: Should companies be required to publicly disclose their environmental impact? Arguments: I. Yes, it would hold companies accountable and help consumers make informed choices. II. No, because the information might be misused.

Answer: Only argument I is strong

5. Statement: Should remote work be made a permanent option for all office employees? Arguments: I. Yes, it reduces commuting costs and time for employees. II. No, because some managers personally prefer seeing employees in the office.

Answer: Only argument I is strong

All 11 practice questions on Statement and Argument, with answers →

Where this comes up

Among the exams Pariksha Saathi covers, Statement and Argument is named in the RRB Group D and RRB ALP reasoning syllabus (as "statement-arguments and assumptions"), and the UP Police Constable syllabus lists "forcefulness of argument"; for any other exam, check your own exam’s official notification. It is closely related to Statement and Assumption and Course of Action, which use the same critical-reasoning skills.

Keep practising

Solve the questions above before opening the answers. Explain each step in your own words, then revisit any mistakes.

Go to practice questions →

Explore the lesson library