Comparison Puzzle Solved Questions
These puzzles give relative comparisons (taller than, shorter than, heavier than) instead of exact positions — the method is to convert every clue into one ordered chain, from the most extreme to the least. Here’s the approach, one shared puzzle with six fully worked questions, and a few more to try yourself.
Written by Mahesh Srivastava, Founder of Pariksha Saathi. Published: 2026-10-03. Editorial standards & corrections
The approach, quickly
- Convert every comparison clue into a "greater than" chain using one consistent symbol as you read: "X is taller than Y" becomes X > Y.
- Combine chains through a person who is the lower end of one and the upper end of the other: if you know C > A and A > B, you can merge them into C > A > B without needing a separate clue connecting C and B directly. If the shared person sits on the same side of both clues (A > B and A > C), you get a branch, not one chain — B and C stay uncompared.
- A clue giving an extreme ("D is the tallest") anchors one end of the whole chain — place it first, the same way an exact position anchors a Seating Arrangement.
- Once every person appears in one single merged chain, answering "who is taller than X" or "how many people are shorter than Y" is just reading positions off that chain.
- Two people can be compared only if a run of clues pointing the same way links them (X > … > Y); an extreme clue such as "D is the tallest" links that person to everyone. If their chains share no common person, or meet only at a branch (A > B and A > C), a question comparing them genuinely "cannot be determined" unless another clue links them.
Worked examples
1. Five friends — A, B, C, D and E — have different heights. A is taller than B. C is taller than A. D is taller than C. E is shorter than B. Who is the tallest among the five?
Solution
- Convert each clue into a chain: D > C (D taller than C), C > A (C taller than A), A > B (A taller than B), B > E (E shorter than B).
- Merging all of these into one chain: D > C > A > B > E.
Answer: D
2. Using the same puzzle and clues, who is the shortest among the five?
Solution
- From the full chain D > C > A > B > E, the last (shortest) person is E.
Answer: E
3. Using the same puzzle and clues, how many people are taller than B?
Solution
- From the chain D > C > A > B > E, the people before B are D, C and A — three people.
Answer: 3
4. Using the same puzzle and clues, who is taller than A but shorter than D?
Solution
- From the chain D > C > A > B > E, the person directly between D and A is C.
Answer: C
5. Using the same puzzle and clues, how many people are shorter than C?
Solution
- From the chain D > C > A > B > E, the people after C are A, B and E — three people.
Answer: 3
6. Using the same puzzle and clues, a sixth friend F is said to be taller than D. Where does F fit in the chain, and who is now the tallest?
Solution
- F > D slots F in at the very top of the existing chain: F > D > C > A > B > E.
Answer: F is the tallest, placed above D
Common mistakes and more worked examples
This section was added on 12 November 2026. It was drafted with AI assistance and checked by a second, independent pass, with every number recomputed. Published by Mahesh Srivastava, who corrects any error you report.
Common mistakes
- Reversing a "shorter than" clue. "E is shorter than B" is written B > E; write every clue with the same symbol, pointing from taller to shorter, before you merge anything.
- Merging two clues whose shared person is on the same side. A > B and A > C say nothing about B and C; draw a branch under A, not a single line, and treat B versus C as undetermined.
- Answering a position question from just one possible order. If N could be either just above or just below L, then "the fourth heaviest" has no single answer; an answer is valid only if it holds in every order the clues allow.
- Saying "cannot be determined" too early. D > C and C > A give D > A even though no clue compares D and A directly; follow every run of clues pointing the same way before giving up.
- Overlooking an extreme clue. "R scored the highest" puts R above everyone, including people R is never compared with; without it, R's place can stay open.
- Counting only the people written next to N in your rough work. For "how many are definitely heavier than N", count everyone linked above N by a run of "heavier than" clues, and leave out anyone whose place relative to N is open.
More worked examples
7. Six students — J, K, L, M, N and O — have different weights. K is heavier than L. J is heavier than K. M is lighter than L. N is lighter than K but heavier than M. O is heavier than J. Who is the lightest, and how many students are definitely heavier than N?
Solution
- Write the clues as chains: O > J > K > L > M (from O > J, J > K, K > L and L > M) and K > N > M.
- N sits below K and above M, but no clue compares N with L. So the clues allow two orders: O > J > K > L > N > M and O > J > K > N > L > M.
- M is last in both orders, so M is the lightest.
- O, J and K are above N in both orders; L is above N in one order and below it in the other. So exactly three students are definitely heavier than N. (The fourth heaviest cannot be determined: it is L in one order and N in the other.)
Answer: M is the lightest; three students (O, J and K) are definitely heavier than N.
8. Five friends — P, Q, R, S and T — scored different marks in a test. R scored the highest. P scored more than Q but less than T. S scored less than Q. Who scored the third highest, and who scored the lowest?
Solution
- "P scored more than Q but less than T" is two clues in one: T > P and P > Q. Adding S < Q gives T > P > Q > S.
- No clue compares R with anyone directly, but "R scored the highest" places R above all four: R > T > P > Q > S.
- The third place is P and the last place is S. Without the clue about R, R could take any of the five places and neither answer would be fixed.
Answer: P scored the third highest; S scored the lowest.
9. Five people — U, V, W, X and Y — have different heights. U is taller than V. W is shorter than V. X is taller than W. Y is shorter than U but taller than X. Which of these statements must be true? I. U is the tallest. II. V is taller than X. III. X is taller than Y.
Solution
- Write the clues as chains: U > V, V > W, X > W, and U > Y > X.
- Merge where the shared person ends one chain and starts the other: U > V > W and U > Y > X > W. Both chains start at U and end at W, so U is the tallest and W the shortest; V's place relative to Y and X is open.
- The possible orders are U > V > Y > X > W, U > Y > V > X > W and U > Y > X > V > W.
- Statement I holds in all three orders, so it must be true. Statement II holds in the first two but not the third, so it could be true but is not certain. Statement III can never be true, because the clues give Y > X.
Answer: Only statement I
Try these yourself
Using the same puzzle and clues above, answer these, then check against the answer.
1. Using the same puzzle and clues, who is the second tallest among the five?
Answer: C
2. Using the same puzzle and clues, how many people are taller than A?
Answer: 2 (D and C)
3. Using the same puzzle and clues, who is immediately shorter than A?
Answer: B
4. Using the same puzzle and clues, who is the third tallest among the five?
Answer: A
5. Using the same puzzle and clues, how many people are taller than E?
Answer: 4 (all of D, C, A and B)
All 11 practice questions on Comparison Puzzles, with answers →
Where this comes up
Comparison Puzzles come under the puzzles in the Reasoning section of exams Pariksha Saathi covers — SSC CGL, RRB NTPC, IBPS PO, IBPS Clerk, SBI PO and SBI Clerk — and use the same chain-building skill as Ranking and Order, just with relative clues instead of numbered ranks. For any other exam, check the Reasoning syllabus in that exam's notification.
Keep practising
Solve the questions above before opening the answers. Explain each step in your own words, then revisit any mistakes.
Go to practice questions →